> Judicial Reviews

Our formal decisions are subject to judicial review by the B.C. Supreme Court. Some of these decisions are further the subject of appeals to the B.C. Court of Appeal. Below you will find a table of pending or completed judicial review proceedings.

Paper copies of court decisions can be obtained from the relevant court. Decisions dating from January 1996 are available at the B.C. Superior Courts' website: http://www.courts.gov.bc.ca/

Clicking on the registry number or case citation of the judicial review below will connect you to the text of the judicial review decision on the B.C. Superior Courts' website. Please note that only cases that have been heard by the court and have been decided will be listed.

Order & Date	Decision Date	Outcome	Registry Number and/or Citation
F09-13 Aug. 11, 2009	JR re 1 item and Schedule 16 - public body has complied with remainder of Order		Vancouver Registry S-096985
F09-07 Apr. 30, 2009	JR not heard yet		Vancouver Registry S-094004
F09-06 Apr. 21, 2009	Oct. 1, 2009	Order partially set aside and remitted back to OIPC for a hearing	Action No. S093711
F09-02 Jan. 27, 2009	JR not heard yet		Vancouver Registry SO97178
F08-22 Dec. 24, 2008	JR not heard yet	Discontinued Nov. 23, 2009	Vancouver Registry S900993
F08-18 Nov. 5, 2008	JR not heard yet		Victoria Registry 09 2882
F08-17 Nov. 5, 2008	JR not heard yet		Victoria Registry 09 2882
Decision F08-07 July 24, 2008	Dec. 10, 2009	Petition dismissed. Decision upheld	2009 BCSC 1700
F08-13 June 27, 2008	JR not heard yet		Vancouver Registry S085647
F08-10 May 21, 2008	Aug. 19, 2009 - public body complied with s. 22 portion of Order	Consent orders setting aside Order F08-10 regarding s. 21 without remittal back to OIPC	Action No. S084717 Action No. S084569
F08-02 Jan. 8, 2008	JR not heard yet		Victoria Registry 08 0510
F08-01 Jan. 4, 2008	Oct. 30, 2009 Nov. 27, 2009	Order Set Aside Appeals Filed	2009 BCSC 1481 S081215 Vancouver Registry
F07-18 Sept. 24, 2007	JR not heard yet		Vancouver Registry S077117
F05-30 Sept. 30/05		Discontinued Jan. 23, 2006
F05-06 Apr. 12, 2005		Discontinued Oct. 17, 2005
04-28 Oct. 29, 2004		Discontinued Oct. 5, 2005
04-05 Feb. 16, 2004	Jan. 27, 2006	Order partially upheld and partially remitted for reconsideration.	2006 BCSC 131
04-04 Feb. 16, 2004	Jan. 27, 2006	Order partially upheld and partially remitted for reconsideration.	2006 BCSC 131
03-14 Mar. 31, 2003	Dec. 3, 2004	Petition successful. Order set aside.	2004 BCSC 1597
03-03 Jan 28, 2003		Discontinued Nov. 19, 2003
02-56 Nov. 14, 2002	Feb 18, 2004	Petition dismissed. Order upheld. Appeal abandoned.	2004 BCSC 217
01-52 Dec. 03, 2001	Oct 11, 2002	Cross-appeals by OIPC and access applicants allowed. Guide Outfitters' appeal dismissed. Order upheld.	2004 BCCA 210
01-40 Aug 23, 2001		Discontinued Nov. 19, 2001
01-39 Aug 16, 2001	Apr 24, 2002	Petition dismissed. Order upheld	2002 BCSC 603
00-50 Nov 9, 2000		Discontinued May 1, 2002
00-24 Jul 17, 2000		Discontinued Dec. 15, 2000
00-22 Jul 11, 2000	Jan 16, 2001	Petition dismissed. Order upheld	2001 BCSC 101
00-11 May 20, 2000		Discontinued July 3, 2002
00-08 Mar 30, 2000	Dec 12, 2002	Petition dismissed by Supreme Court. Court of Appeal upheld the s. 14 finding, but quashed the s. 13(1) decision. Leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada denied.	2002 BCCA 665
322-99 Jul 30, 1999	May 12, 2003	Petition successful. Order set aside. Appeal dismissed.	2003 BCCA 278
308-99 May 7, 1999	Jun 15, 2000	Petition successful. Order set aside	99 2641 Victoria BC Supreme Court
293-99 Feb 15, 1999	Dec 21, 1999	Decision to allow fee waiver upheld. Ministry appealed, but appeal later was abandoned.	99 1290 Victoria BC Supreme Court
290-99 Feb 11, 1999	JR not yet heard.
281-98 Dec 7, 1998	Jun 3, 1999	Petition successful. Order set aside	99 0019 Victoria BC Supreme Court [1999] B.C.J. No 1283
S. 43-12 Jan 29, 1998	Jun 24, 1998	Petition successful. Authorization set aside and remitted for re-consideration	A98 0731 Vancouver BC Supreme Court
S. 43-11 Dec 19, 1997	JR not yet heard
195-97 Oct 23, 1997	Nov 5, 1998	Petition dismissed. Order upheld.	A97 2947 Vancouver BC Supreme Court
S. 43-10 Oct 22, 1997	JR not yet heard
144-97 Jan 17, 1997	Feb 3, 1999	Petition successful. Order partially set aside and partially remitted for reconsideration. Reconsideration cancelled July 8, 1999	A97 0437 Vancouver BC Supreme Court
S. 43-3 Oct 31, 1996	Dec 2, 1997	Authorization upheld (but the absolute prohibition would have been remitted had it not already expired).	A97 0544 Vancouver BC Supreme Court
126-96 Sep 17, 1996	Mar 17, 2000	Petition successful. Order partially quashed, and remitted for reconsideration. Petitioner withdrew April 26, 2000. New decision is Order 01-02.	A97 1236 Vancouver BC Supreme Court
115-96 Aug 23, 1996	Jul 8, 1998	Petition dismissed. Order upheld.	A96 2846 Vancouver BC Supreme Court
108-96 May 30, 1996	Aug 5, 1997	Petition successful. Order remitted for reconsideration and reissued as Order 108A	A96 2692 Vancouver BC Supreme Court
74-95 Dec 22, 1995	Sep 25, 1996	Petition successful. Order set aside.	A96 0275 Vancouver BC Supreme Court
73-95 Dec 21, 1995	Jan 21, 1997	Petition dismissed by consent order.	A96 0195 Vancouver BC Supreme Court
61-95 Nov 1, 1995	Oct 15, 1996	Petition successful. Order set aside.	A95 4022 Vancouver BC Supreme Court
56-95 Oct 4, 1995	Mar 8, 1996	Petition dismissed. Order upheld	A95 3676 Vancouver BC Supreme Court
48-95 Jul 7, 1995	Aug 18, 1998	Petition dismissed. Order upheld. Appeal dismissed.	CA 022585 Vancouver BC Court of Appeal
39-95 Apr 24, 1995	Sep 30, 1997	Petition dismissed without reasons. Order upheld.	S031050 N. Westminster BC Supreme Court
36-95 Mar 3, 1995	Sep 11, 1997	Petition successful. Order set aside. Appeal abandoned.	A95 1426 Vancouver BC Supreme Court
29-94 Nov 3, 1994	Dec 12, 1995	Petition successful. Order set aside.	A94 3843 Vancouver BC Supreme Court
22-94 Sep 1, 1994	Nov. 28, 1995	Petition dismissed. Order upheld.	A94 2824 Vancouver BC Supreme Court
8-94 May 26, 1994	Dec 12, 1994	Petition successful. Order set aside and remitted for reconsideration. Later reissued as Order 48-94.	A94 1851 Vancouver BC Supreme Court